The Structural Problems in David Deutsch’s Framework and Brett Hall’s Defense: When “Hard to Vary” Becomes Easy to Dodge
How a YouTube Comment Exposed Unfalsifiable Foundations Beneath Rigorous-Sounding Philosophy The Setup: A Critique That Deserved Better I encountered Brett Hall (https://www.bretthall.org/about.html) through YouTube’s recommendation algorithm. His video critiquing Michael Levin’s “basal cognition” framework appeared in my feed, and within the first ten minutes, I recognized something valuable: Hall had identified a genuine problem with…


![What Shape Is Persistence? Why Douglas Brash’s Observation the Ship of Theseus Is a Wave Is Insightful (And Why That Is Not the Whole Answer) [Physics, Biology, Neuroscience]](https://sweetrationalism.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Screenshot-2026-02-18-185254-768x713.png)





